IAS Vs IIM (MBA) Debate!!
Time and again.. this is the question which keeps trickling.. in the minds of almost every student of our country. The reasons for this are varied. Well.. i m not gonna mention all.. but would essentially try to throw light on some.. one by one..
Lemme began the first by quoting, an excerpt from our national pink dailies - The Economic Times or ET as it is popularly known.
TIMES NEWS NETWORK[ MONDAY, MARCH 22, 2004 02:10:43 PM ]
MUMBAI: While one acronym symbolises power, the other symbolises pelf....
Quite true.. as said above.. IAS is the gateway to power.. whereas an MBA from IIM opens door to Dollar Salaries.. Working in Dream Companies.. and so on!
Every year.. once the placements in these Centres of Excellence gets over.. this question arises again..!! The reason.. the graduates from these institutes are offered start-up salaries which an IAS, IFS or IPS officer would make close to the end of a career spanning three decades.
This salary imbalance often lead to uncomfortable situations.. putting the student in a dilemna whether he should go for an MBA or a Career in Civil Services.. which is said to be the prestigious career since British Raj The IAS is seen as an illustrious career-path that could do wonders to one's self-esteem and could rocket the family repute as well.
I can elaborate on this much more.. but for now.. i invite you to comment on this post.. about what would you have gone in for and why if given a choice between the two!!
I 'll definitely get back to this post again soon..
Till then.. Goodbye from me!
posted by Sach @ 8:15 PM
147 Comments:
IIM MBA CAT
hi..every one..
ias r mba...?????
wat to prepare for...cat r civils...?????
ooh god help me out... get me a solution..with all de + , - 's for choosing dat track ....
cat seems quite easy to crack compared to civils...
i got only 2 years left...before leaving dis iit kgp...
i hav to do som thing ... first clear my dilemma ...
rajesh.ravipati@gmail.com
yar , frankly speaking ias offers you the platform from where you can really work to improve the various levels of society.the job of ias provides diversified experience of life........which is always exciting for a guy who cant settle for monotonous job ....ultimately your work directly influences the countrys future......isnt so exciting?well ofcourse u dont get big salary packets as in mba.......but life is not money-machine...........and country like india where u need thousands and thousands life to know it........i always feel job of 30 yrs in ias is still short
if money is ur only goal go for iim
if you need power and satisfaction in your job prefer civils
ias or iim..
An ias officer is a pet of politicians.. an uneducated politician can hav ful control over an ias officer,esp.tranferring anywhere at his will..
ias- prestige,less pay better perks.
iim- great salary,more working hours and stress.
I asked this particular question a lot.Most of the time answer is "POWER".I can't understand what kind of power people seek.IAS are vested with power,power to change the society, to eradicate socio-economic problems.To choose any career is measured only on job satisfaction...and for me it is by being an IAS or a civil servant.This way I can serve my country directly with maximum efficiency and be satisfied.Obviously I shall get a bacon light car with a VIP status and a bodyguard.
Hi everyone..
I just want to list the pros and cons in IAS and IIM(MBA) as of my knowledge.
Pros in IAS:
1.Power,power,power
2.Prestige,challenging work in district,divisional and central levels
3.Facilities,respect ,contacts etc
4.If you move back from any service to corporate world after some years,you will be paid more than your peers.
cons in IAS:
1.less money.
2.remote working places in the begining of the career...any rural district
3.No metrolife...no multiplexes,no pizzahuts,no pubs and discos...this is the one most disliked for me
4.requires hard work and dedication to get in
5.political pressures
pros in IIM(MBA)
1.more money,luxurious life
2.Challenging work life
3.Metro life...hospitals,international schools for children,fun and entertainment
4.independent thinking and innovation
cons in IIM(MBA)
1.no power in society..may be in his/her firm.
2.No govt facilities
3.lots of working hours...of course as an IAS servant you should be promised to work 24*7
still i am in dilemma which one should i select?
I like sme gud features in IAS and some gud features in IIM(MBA).i couldnt able to decide ...
I flipped many times between these two
guys ,please post your opinions also...suggest me ASAP
i would be gr8ful to u ,if u solve my problem
I dont hav any contacts of IAS/IIM graduates..or else i could have met them and clarified my doubts
waiting for ur reply
Thanx a ton in anticipation
Regards
Anish
bak.040@gmail.com
The ones like Anish should never come to civils!
Why?
Simply because the one in civils must be ready to sacrifice much more than that Anish is bothered about.("No metrolife...no multiplexes,no pizzahuts,no pubs and discos...this is the one most disliked for me"-Anish)
comparing IAS with IIM IS JUST A Foolishness. Its upto the individual that what he/she wants to do in their life. you just want to earn money or you want to do something for your society,where you will be decision makers of your country. One thing fore sure that in management sector, one will be focussed within one sector only, whereas in ias you may land up in different sectors, lot mny situations to tackled out there, lot many challenges. So, its a matter of choice.. power or money..
hi..everyone..
yah its corect that ias pay scale is very less compared to mba..but it is satisfactory and you can fullfill almost every need.moreover you get many government fascilities like bunglow(in civil lines),driver,bodyguard,maid etc.what else you want....!
i have completed mba and confuse with to go for civil or naukri
hi,there is no comparision of ias with iim ,ias are far ahead in every aspect in terms of power as well in money also
Who knows where to download XRumer 5.0 Palladium?
Help, please. All recommend this program to effectively advertise on the Internet, this is the best program!
sachblogs.blogspot.com is very informative. The article is very professionally written. I enjoy reading sachblogs.blogspot.com every day.
payday loans edmonton payday
Good Day!!! sachblogs.blogspot.com is one of the most excellent resourceful websites of its kind. I enjoy reading it every day. All the best.
25mg tylenol Canadian cialis World shippind relafen 10mg shuddha guggulu Order phenergan Buy kamagra
The author of sachblogs.blogspot.com has written an excellent article. You have made your point and there is not much to argue about. It is like the following universal truth that you can not argue with: The moon is still revolving around the earth. Thanks for the info.
sachblogs.blogspot.com; You saved my day again.
sachblogs.blogspot.com is the best. Thank your for this article. I enjoyed it very much.
AAA Toronto Payday Loans 1172 Bay St #101, Toronto, ON M5S 2B4 (416) 477-2817
I AM STUDYING ENGINEERING AND THATS IT
Really there is no comparision between civils and MBA.It is much better to choose Civils rather than MBA.MBA helps you to live for yourself where as IAS helps to live for the country.Our country's present and as well as future depends on Your service as an IAS officer.
self satisfaction is the basic factor that should be considered.ias officers have to face political pressure whereas mba have to work under stress 24*7.
About me, I have completed my engineering and placed in an mnc.
Its not the only matter of power and money. But the most important thing is that we got to live with our family members also happily. Its not possible through MBA so easily. But it is very much easy for an IAS officer to live anywhere around the country. One thing more, money is not less for an ias officer.
so, the last chance is yours.
can anybody help me out in subject selection for getting through in civil services ? Please mail me at
saurabh86.shekhar@gmail.com
I wil be very much thankful to you.
amazingly..., i can identify with most of the ppl above...
though i am not confused about what to go for....
i always wanted to do i.a.s....!!!
but it has alot of ups n downs(talking about the preparation) n it has a highly uneven track to traverse.
i am in d.u doing chem hons final yr.. n im clueless whether i should prepare for mba or not bcoz in the end it is ias i want to go for.
can any of you suggest me any good post graduation course which could later help me to prepare for ias...???
please mail me @ divya2222@gmail.com
i think both streams are worthier enough. it depends on wht type of life do u seek?metro life ...........exposure to the world.....go for iims.otherwise ..........
and what seems to u as power has many restrction as well
ias--- exceptional hard work,exceptional power that too at a very young age, gateway to india's most lucrative job i.e.politics, exceptional reputation, exceptional fame, exceptional money(according to ur choice)...exceptional opportunity to form opinion on almost every topic under the sun....ranging from vedas to hollywood...finally ias is all about serving the aspirations of millions.......cabinet secretary the top most for an ias runs the econmoy of $1tn for more than 1 bn people...
MBA(IIM)-----hard work, gud reputation, exceptional exposure to corporate world, exceptional money,gud fame, almost unidimensional approach (i.e. optimising profit in terms of financia transaction).finally mab is all about selling something.....
the top most for an mba runs a company
See if u choose iim there is definately lot of money in it but in fact even in civil services there is sufficient money according to 6th pay comission...civil services are best...
why the hell is it always about money..?? people are earning huge packages just to raise their standard of living..that is they might buy mercedes,ferrari..just to gain respect but once you are an IAS officer you'll easily get that respect..!! and the thing about metro life and pizza hut..!! you can enjoy that as well..take a leave and travel the world..!! you can always take a sabbatical if you want to study more..!! and the political pressure thing..if you even slap a politicain he can't do any any thing to you..he only posses power to tranfer you..or put you in aloop line...in case of an iim grad..if you slap your boss..you'll then have to find a new job.>!
still guy's MBA route is much easier then the IAS.
i will have to wait for a year after 4 yrs of engineering...because i will not be 21yrs old on August 1 of my year of passing out the institute.shud i prepare for ias...or go for mba after passin out and den prepare for ias...
Yaar, there is no comparison between IAS and IIM. Look, IAS is nothing but a career indulge with most repectable in society and commendabel job. It enhence not only to you but your family get the zoom like rocket in the sky while IIM pass out is just doing a lucrative package job in tata, reliance or some other MNC.
Overall, IIM can be cracked surely with serious preparation of 6 months but for IAS its 2 years rigorous hard work and still not confirmed taht whether later would be cleared or not.
HI All,
Its Gourav from itbhu.
I donno y ppl think an IIM PG can't serve our nation. There are plethora of examples, where you find an IIM PGP pass out, carrying responsibilities of national importance. You cant ignore those ppl who r running their own entrepreneurship cells and serving the nation in a better way, than an ias officer can do. Here i am not discouraging the ias aspirants bt the desire to serve ones nation can be fulfilled in any of these two ways.
e-mail-gourav.itbhu@gmail.com
Well, I'm son of an IAS officer and my all friends are into MBA (IIMs & IITs)...when people talk about innovative skills involved in MBA I have a point. That can be applied in civils feild too. I have seen many IAS officers opening various schools in suburban areas, forest officers are in demand as green managers in this global warming era. End of the day I fully agree that preparations for an IAS is the most difficult aspect but if you see the pain not the gain you are the loser.Nothing can be compared to IAS or for that matter the country governance of any country is THE MOST PRESTIGIOUS JOB ONE CAN DO.If you seriously want to stand tall in this world IAS is way to go. Immense recognition, exceptional perks, decent salary and to top it all inner satisfaction. If you want to start your own business probably IAS officers (though historically they aren't oriented that way but someone has to start and it can be you)have an upper hand coz they gain huge benifits as they are in the government. I am too an indian forest service aspirant and if I carck it, doing job will not be my only life, I will certainly apply all my engineering and managerial skills in opening some kind of "green" firm or NGO to save earth from climate change. Lastly, no comparision between an IAS and an IIM. Management is a mean minded course where you have to fool your customers through lucrative offers even if they don't need it. For civils, if you are honest enough, you can do wonders coz no matter what you do, you'll never get fired and you can carry on.....
hi guys......comparing ias with iim is totally unusual..ias is much ahead n better as compared to iim...though in iim there is money but there is no respect,free facilities n most importantly the AUTHORITY...in a crowded area an ias officer will have a distinct personality..iam an ias aspirant n iam 19 years old n iam preparing to appear in upsc 2013 exam..so in last the final conclusion according to me is that ias is best n above all...
I am working in Corporate IT world and currently 29Yrs of age (7 Yrs. of Exp in IT). Every person has its own perception to it, whether IAS or IIM?
See my Thinking below:
IIM is just for selfish people who wants to earn Money for themselves and to hell with rest of the world.
IAS is reputed and powerful profession where is person can do a lot to his country.
IIM - Suppose if you are going on a road and by chance get in scuffle with any rickshaw wala or any Hawaldaar (Constable), he can just beat you up mercilessly.
IAS - People just cry to even have a handshake with you.
These are just day to day routine examples, Choice is yours.
My elder bro currently studies at IIM A .I to was thinking of appearing CAT.His life there n the things he tells abt his profs, colleg life etc facinates me very much.But lately heard abt IAS the power, respect etc..
so At this moment I to am confused abt IAS or IIM.Almost evryone i sked told me that IAS ppl get kots of bribe in cluding the salery.
Mr.dreamboat - Kindly elaborate what you want in life?
Money or Respect?
If you are money minded and can sell your integrity for Money go for IIM,,else if you want to do something for your country go for IAS. rest bribe thing depends on you.,,,no one if forcing you, it your decision. OKAY
I am from a top 5 MBA insti. Currently working for 1yr in an MNC. And I am very dissatisfied. They make you work like dog (weekends, late nights). Money is above average but not superb. There is no power. You are treated like slave (more so inside the company, at the beginning atleast). There is very less honesty, humanity. Motto is earn mone, by hook or by crook.
Now seriously thinking of leaving the job & maybe preparing for IAS..
i will choose ias inspite of mba as respect is more important to me than salary..............
Corporate job is ONLY for SELFISH people who can SELL themselves for MONEY......All CORPORATES ARE PATHETIC PEOPLE.........
IAS is the best profession where in you have a choice to be a corrupt or HONEST, Moreover RESPECT is incomparable at all....
but in corporate there is no option......
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ISbyQBi7QVk&feature=related
Guyz watch this....see What is an IAS for a common man.....??
IAS is the BEST profession......
- Deepak
ARRAY YAR SABSE BADIYA BED KARO AUR GOVT SKOOL MEIN TEACHER BANN JAO GAON MEIN AISH KARO!KAHE IAS KI TENSION AUR CORPORATE KA NATAK LETE HO
the whole discussion about iim, ias
seems great and surely an eye opener for most of us.different people have different opinions and more or less they are equally correct.i am a 1st year student having same issues and to be honest i am still not sorted thanks to the pleothra of views and opinions posted.such dilemma is justified as after all who dose'nt want a fulfilled life with the satisfaction of serving people and at the same time leading a luxurious life.i'll give my final conclusions later on after i sort out myself on this inevitable debate.
in fact....both ias and iim require equal levels of determination....in tha case of ias the person needs to study hard by isolating himself from the world during his preparation while remaining in touch with every thing around him......while in the case of iim as well the student needs to go through tough examination procedures as well.....today as we can see the students who get even 99.9% in the cat are not selected by the iims due to various reasons.ultimately the two lines are equally demanding..in tha case of mba tha person gets huge money hile in ias it's not....
some facts:
1. It is true that IAS officers enjoy power and authority but they can do so within a constitutional framework only. Any extra costitutional power or authority enjoyed by any govt officer is against law and shameful.
2. People forget that policy formation and decision making is a collective process and it is not at all the case that IAS officers can take independent decisions.
3. Indian population at large has not been able to shed that pre-independence mentality that govt and govt officers are supreme in the society unlike western societies where entrepreneurship is valued more.
4. Point to be understood here is that a businessman establishes a business which would last for generations whereas an IAS officer derives power an authority by virtue of his position which is bound to go once he retires.
5. People who think that IAS officers can improve the society should understand that bureaucracy has only added to society problems and hsa done less to solve it. Red tapism is a shame.
6. Someone has well said 'Every politics is economics'. Bureaucracy can't alone run this country. We need visionary politicians, able administrators, good managers, good teachers, excellent sports person, fabulous actors to develop this nation. In short every indian citizen is equally responsible and not only ias officer or iim grad.
Hope this discussion is of some help. Thanks.
see 1st of all there are 2 catagories in IAS,
1)to enjoy the power ,to can make huge money ,property ,name ,fame,to make yours a classic family
2)really working for the country,on the behalf of poor people,farmers and your life will be defintely satisfy with this, ias offers you the platform from where you can really work to improve the various levels of society.the job of ias provides diversified experience of life........which is always exciting for a guy who cant settle for monotonous job ....ultimately your work directly influences the countrys future.....ahh what a life HERO of ur country.
in IIM,
TALENT , money ,luxury
but u r a big ZERO(means not that much explosure) in the society
ias definitely provides a platform to make lasting impression in society but ias officers use this platform for self improvement, society hardly benefits. Actually, by adding more ias officers, we are introducing more hurdles in the way of development. I would strongly suggest top govt posts be made open for non ias cadres thru lateral entry sceme as is the practice in USA. This would end the monopoly currently being enjoyed by ias.
The above discussion makes it clear that whether we should go for ias or mba....but how to recognize whether we r capable for ias preparations or not???
The only edge IIMs got over IAS is luxurious and affluent life it renders otherwise IAS is always an better option...An important point to mull is that all of us making the choice between the two are mainly between the age group of 20-25. And at this age we have more inclination towards the glitters and shines of urban city (read some post about worry to miss pizza hut & malls etc.)..but provided we have to make choice between the two at the age of say 30-35, we could have been very decisive and may confidently voted for IAS as a better field because then u realize life is much more than making money and spending it crazily on unearthly things..(Note..any figure u earn its always insufficient..always ther is need for more)...so in long run as an IAS officer u will find your life more complete and purposeful. and its not gud to be myopic while deciding your career path as it determines your life, your achievements.
This was my view, also i would like to add both (iim n ias)being the epitome of their field, u need to have an whole-hearted approach to clear it. so dont start your prepration while you muddling between the two. take your time, decide what you really want in life..it may take months but finally u will be much more focussed and wud have 10 times better chance to clear the exam..
ALL D BEST..!! Since you guys have such big ambitions, i can say U will always excel in your life..!!
thanx everyone for this wonderful debate experience and now im gettng to knw wat i want in my lyf... in the near future
yes our future generation is more inclined towards the urban society and we just got attracted towards this
but in my opinion we shuld think more of our future than to think of our urban present
we can also enjoy metro lyf as an ias officer....
this is manav gandhi
Newday_Newsun.....
Ask a simple question to yourself. Do we all have to be an IAS officer to serve the society?...............
We dont have to be an IAS officer to serve the nation..IAS refers to serve society is utter crap.. be a doctor, scientist, teacher etc and play your honest role for society. Once you do that thn u get the real feel of peace called satisfaction. Do whatever u wanna do , IAS,IIM, LLB, CCIE etc,, but u can serve nation antime
take care mates
Hi guys
Seems there is some war between the guys supporting an IAS and an eunterprenuers. Alright before commenting anything I would like to say that I am a chemical engineering graduate from BITS Pilani(class 2010)(guys m not braggin please :D). I know a lot of my friends have started their own firm in bangalore and will surely be successful eunterprenuers in future. A EEE senior bagged 4th rank in UPSC and recently I friend of mine bagged Rs. 1 crore from some bank(obviously doller converted :P IIM A grad).
Coming to the point, being an IAS officer, an euterprenuer or an investment banker is purely an individuals ambition. U have to decide how u want to die(as among the above mention :D). Justifying your ambitions over others taking others names/profession is bullshit.
Well whatever u do, if u can live with it is kool. U can serve the nation by being any of the above. There is no debate over it.
Now coming to my short autobiography :P. I too wanted to become an IAS officer when I was in XIIth. I prepared for IIT JEE, ended in BITS. Now have given CAT n hopefully would fit in some IIM and then I plan to start a technology driven company. Yes Over the last 6 years, many times I thought of preparing for UPSC, eradicate corruption, fight against the corrupt politicians, remove social inequality by being an IAS oficer. But it's not so easy guys when u don't get even 10% of what an investment banker gets. At this point of time I can say I can help myself, my nation more effectively by being an eunterprenuer than being an IAS officer. This is just my case. No generalization please. If u think u can serve yourself and then nation by being an IAS officer and not an eunterprenuer, well go for it. :Respect.
"To conclude, u can do whatever u want to do(serving yourselves and nation) only if u r satisfied with your profession and do what u think is great work. There is no point fighting on threads like this and justfying 1s opinion."
PS: Chetan Bhagat an IIT/IIM grad leaves his job as an investment banker and is now writing books that is undoubtedly changing the society...Kool job!!!
It is entirely a matter of personal interest i.e. what exactly a person is inclined towards,..... both IIM & IAS are good options, but the only thing is do you really love the job profile?????
IAS if u want to serve your Nation..and help the needy peoples and contribute for development of your nation...Power and Perks doesn't matters...here matters Interest
If you really compare the 2 fields in terms of salary u bettter opt for CAT. The one who really want to serve people, help poor, resolve the social problems will go towards I.A.S without bothering about salary or workload.......!!!!!!
If you really compare the 2 fields in terms of salary u bettter opt for CAT. The one who really want to serve people, help poor, resolve the social problems will go towards I.A.S without bothering about salary or workload.......!!!!!!
hi every body............
this debate is never gonna end because it depends upon individual thinking. I am also facing the same d same dilemma but it should certainly come to an end as it is matter of our career. Taking others help will always confuse us more. So all who are facing with the same dilemma should ask themselves a question that what qualities they are having just clearing the exam will not ensure that you will become successful in that field whether it is ias or mba. So personal attributes are important. Imagine urself as an ias officer or an mba professional think in which field u can perform better ur inner self will give u the answer, then choose the career. Its the fact also that obstacles in IAS will be more u can not work according to your thinking. According to me name & fame due to person's own personality & thinking is much more than by his or her post. So decide in which career ur personality will be more groomed then opt for that.
hi evry one...im sridevi...im also in the same dilemma..whether to choose civils or mba...but after a deep thinking and deep discussion i have found out an answer for me...that is i will choose civils..bcz if i choose mba i would be a normal unidentified person..if i choose civils i will be an identified person and has power in my hands...i would feel great if i would get a chance to serve the society..In money vs power always power wins...thanks to everybodys valuable suggestions
if one is capable .....ias is the best..there are many ways of earning money apart from being an iim mba,,,,
IIM is best to do MBA. They have good teachers for MBA course. They can teach you good in brief and easily.
MBA Colleges in Mumbai
IAS Vs IIM - Debate Conclusion!
IAS - Cabinet Secretary leads a country of 1.2 billion with $1 trillion economy.
Selfless Service
Works to make the poor rich.
Respectful
IAS is an Acronym for Power
Should have balls to take on the powerful elemets
Has temperment to be calm when hit hard for doing the right
Should be a good manager of power
IIM - Entreprenuer leading a group of comapnies
Selfish
Works to make the rich richer
Luxurious
Lots of money
Can work without balls
Needs stress managment
Should be a good manager of money
guys debate will continue longer.the only thing i would like to highlight is the power to make decision and to do the respectful job in society. i also appered for cat last year but suddenly after seeing the life style of mba guys.i cab bet that except on IIM a,b,c graduate one would have to struggle a lot.both IAS and CAT require devotion.IAS officer is being observed by goverment organisation after retirement in advisory commite of the nation.so surely IAS is unequivocale and imcomparible with the rest money making job.AN enterprenur serve first himself fully then start business and make money and say it a nation service.only if you have the capacity ti established a company like REliance nad tata then only yiuy can debate on mba VS ias
guys debate will continue longer.the only thing i would like to highlight is the power to make decision and to do the respectful job in society. i also appered for cat last year but suddenly after seeing the life style of mba guys.i cab bet that except on IIM a,b,c graduate one would have to struggle a lot.both IAS and CAT require devotion.IAS officer is being observed by goverment organisation after retirement in advisory commite of the nation.so surely IAS is unequivocale and imcomparible with the rest money making job.AN enterprenur serve first himself fully then start business and make money and say it a nation service.only if you have the capacity ti established a company like REliance nad tata then only yiuy can debate on mba VS ias
Most of the people whom I have seen preparing for IAS are always concerned about the power that this job promises.......They start preparing for IAS just because of the "Power Factor" and not because they want to bring about a change in the society....How selfish is that? I leave it for you to decide.....On similar lines, as you people say, that IIM graduates are enamored by the high pay packages which this brand name guarantees.... So the logical deduction is that both are selfish....one for power and the other one for money......But the real difference is in the intellectual capability of the two ...An IIT\NIT grad having an IIM degree will be far more intellectually capable than a IAS guy , who is an average B Sc. or a B Tech from some tier 2 college and gets into IAS after preparing for 3-5 years....
FROM : AN IIM GRADUATE
Hello there,
Recently i cracked 3 exams : SBI PO, CDS UPSC, CAT.
But my dream is different. Ofcourse it is to have a lavish life, global exposure, celebrating life, lot of white money, FAME-NAME-MONEY... but then there goes... The X-factor..The magic to change things and its called 'POWER'. And being an IAS,you have the magic wand. Well, been from military school, I do love adventures and If i make it through- I can choose 'IPS'. Or if you are too crazy about representing your country-then 'IFS', where in, you not only impact the relations of two great nations but of 1000 corporate businesses and not just 1 by being an IIM Graduate! And who says economically a bureaucrat is an average being?? I bet, to be true and practical, the packages that IIM graduate gets annually, here, if you are in the right department, its montly. + you can change the society... if you managed smartly and accurately the political/Govt support. 'RESPECT' - well well well -> The CEO myt roam in Rolls Royce but the glowing lamp on the car would always be superior! IAS would always be the first citizen. I do agree that An IIT\NIT grad having an IIM degree will be far more intellectually capable than a IAS guy , who is an average B Sc. or a B Tech from some tier 2 college and gets into IAS after preparing for 3-5 years, but his influence would be beyond the reach of former. To debate there would be many things on the list but one thing sure : IIM wins only if in the end you successfully become AMBANIs or TATAs or MITTALs or Azim Premjis and if not... well, lets end the debate!
raj says
ias wins
kishor says,
Both are respectable jobs in their own field,but it depends from individual to individual.A lot depends on the personality of the candidate.The iim offers you more money and wealth,but there is onedrawback, they usually deal only with middle and upper strata of society.They have no connection with poor people.In a country like india where most of the people are poor(60 crore out of 120 crore) we cant keep them at bay for our self development.Of course Ias gives you more opportunity to help the needy when you become DM,Secretary or commissioner.
Mr. Vijay Kamthe.......Private sector is responsible for 3/4 th of the GDP of our country.....IAS officers have been there for ages but they can not change the shape of the country.....They can only formulate rules and policies for the corporate sector which are largely influenced by the lynchpins of the corporate sector.....But it is the people in the private sector who actually take the country forward......Only after the liberalization in 1991 , our country has seen tremendous growth and IT revolution driven by the corporate sector is responsible for that....I will give you a very simple analogy.....IAS are like the cricket administrators who formulate selection policies and rules .....but corporate are like the players who go out there in the field and bring laurels to the nation .......Now my question to you is that, who do you respect more?........Kris srikanth as a selector or sachin tendulkar as a player....I am talking about the bigger picture.....just read some books on how Indian Economy has developed over the years and you will realize who has made the real difference to the society......Corporates or the IAS....
Mr Kishore.......Business, either small scale or large scale has given employment to a lot of poor people who otherwise would have continued to languish.....What govt does (in conjunction with the IAS) is that it doles out subsidies to the poor people which never reaches the intended beneficiaries....That is there way of dealing with the poor.....They leave the employment generation to the private sector .....and this is what will pull them out of poverty rather then the subsidies which government offers.....
Mr Kishore.......Business, either small scale or large scale has given employment to a lot of poor people who otherwise would have continued to languish.....What govt does (in conjunction with the IAS) is that it doles out subsidies to the poor people which never reaches the intended beneficiaries....That is there way of dealing with the poor.....They leave the employment generation to the private sector .....and this is what will pull them out of poverty rather then the subsidies which government offers.....
I totally agree with you "IIM Graduate"......IAS is just an exam for which you prepare behind closed doors or at best go to a coaching institute .....it does not develop your personality or change your thought process as a human being.......On the contrary IIM is a full time course where after preparing and cracking one of the toughest aptitude exam you interact with some of the sharpest brains in the country for 2 years......You are mentored by some of the best mentors in the country.....IAS does not offer anything of that sort initially....Later there are opportunities but nothing like an IIM ....the two can not be compared.....One is a full time course and other is an exam......
Hi Prateek,,,,Loved the way you supported IIM Graduate....Most of the points which you guys have emphasized on are true and pragmatic..
But I think you guys have somewhat bragged about the 'intellectual part'...
If I take ur points that IIT-IIM-NIT grads form the intellectual covens of the 1.2bn people then why can't they devise some entrepreneural ideas to help the people who are below the BPL to get above the Poverty Line??
Why can't those 'intellectually superior ' grads find a common solution to fight the economic meltdown??
Why do Govts' have to help bankrupt companies if corporate lynchpins have formulated the world policies and influenced world economy more than Govt servants??
I just have these doubts and many more to ask from the corporates??
clomid without period | order clomid no prescription - buy clomid without prescription uk, when do you ovulate after clomid
Post69, http://www.arlo.net/massacree/ viagra online in uk, msvr9, http://www.arlo.net/fccgb/ buy viagra without prescription, nvfs9, http://www.arlo.net/fccgb/notes/ generic viagra online, ztvu7, http://www.arlo.net/bytes/ cheap viagra online, vran6, http://www.arlo.net/live/ viagra sale online
Well I am in NSIT (got a 3 digit AIR,Far better than most NITs)
Intelectually many IITians also give IAS so how can they be less smarter than IIT-IIM.
Infact upsc is much tougher so they can me attributed as smarter, and as far as clearing an exam is concerned, even IIT jee and CAT is prepared with slogging.
UPSC also has personality test which tests life skills.
And An IAS officer can also start businesses and be an entrepreneur... He has more power and time(which helps)
Money , i think any IAS can make more money (more than 100 times that of an I-banker) smartly...
He can at the same time have power.
And Really manouever the black money into benefit of poor.
Please share your take on this Mr. IIM Grad
generic viagra viagra online natural - viagra discovery
[url=http://loveepicentre.com/articles.php][img]http://loveepicentre.com/uploades/photos/11.jpg[/img][/url]
iran free dating site [url=http://loveepicentre.com/]thialand dating women[/url] phone dating u
baltic single dating ladies [url=http://loveepicentre.com/map.php]tagg dating site[/url] latin telephone dating free trial code
french women dating [url=http://loveepicentre.com/]new zealand 100 free dating[/url] ziva and toni dating
[url=http://loveepicentre.com/faq.php][img]http://loveepicentre.com/uploades/photos/11.jpg[/img][/url]
uk gay online dating feeds [url=http://loveepicentre.com/]dating in the uk[/url] stories danger internet dating
internet dating denver [url=http://loveepicentre.com/success_stories.php]dating in magazine[/url] local free dating sites
dating hamilton watch models [url=http://loveepicentre.com/articles.php]dating in the federal government[/url] dating service in arlington texas
www.blogger.com owner you are great
[url=http://luv-2-share-pics.tumblr.com]hot girls pics[/url]
buy soma soma online usa - how to buy somatropin
purchase soma soma intimates - soma medication migraines
carisoprodol soma soma 350 mg erowid - buy qualitest soma online
cheap soma online drug interactions for soma - soma class of drug
buy soma order soma - buy soma online usa
buy soma online soma nursing bra - can soma pills get you high
tramadol 50 mg tramadol 50 mg what is it for - tramadol 75 mg
xanax online klonopin xanax and alcohol - xanax 0.5mg dosage
order alprazolam no prescription xanax drug test detection time - order xanax online europe
generic xanax xanax online no prescription india - what color is generic xanax
The musculаrity of tantric massage travels much more than my hаnԁlіng, I went into labor!
Do thеy or join me on facebook so you will be updateԁ when your anѕwer is posted.
It's a admonisher of freedom for it's clock time to do
it all οnce mогe!
Also see my site :: tantric massage
alprazolam online xanax side effects withdrawal - xanax 1mg street value
buy tramadol buy tramadol online safe - tramadol hydrochloride capsules 50mg side effects
buy tramadol tramadol 50 mg for cramps - tramadol renal dosing
generic xanax klonopin xanax drug interactions - generic xanax pill id
alprazolam online xanax you buy online real - buy yellow xanax bars
buy carisoprodol carisoprodol generic name - 350 mg carisoprodol generic soma
buy generic cialis order cialis online reviews - cialis 10 mg daily
xanax online is xanax good for opiate withdrawal - generic xanax gg 256
Hi everyone...After reading all comments, I thought best way to conclude between both is to compare them on the basis of different needs of one’s life.
1. Money
Yeah I do agree that you can earn lot of money after doing MBA from IIM's , but thing is that after doing MBA you can get job only in Metros like Mumbai, Delhi or Bangalore and things in these Metros are much costlier than a normal A grade city.
I am living in Mumbai and according to my Statistics a normal 2BHK flat cost you around 2-3 crores in North Mumbai and you have to pay minimum 5-6 crores if you want buy it in South Mumbai.
So tell me guys if you are 3 lacs per month, then how many years will it take to buy a normal 2BHK flat in a Metro. The answer is atleast 20-25 years.
But in IAS you will get Bungalow all the time you will get a transfer.
And 50-60K is enough in a A grade city.
2. Satisfaction
If you are working in a corporate world after doing MBA, guys please forget about the satisfaction.
I have seen that people at the level of MD are not satisfied with the work.
It’s not necessary that all the time your family is in a need, you will get the leave. In corporate world only things matter are business and Client.
But on the other hand no doubt IAS life is busy too but atleast you can save the time which these MBA people will waste in Traffic jams (atleast 2 hours daily).
buy cialis no prescription buy cialis online using paypal - cialis daily how long
At this moment I am going to do my breakfast, after having my breakfast coming over again to read
more news.
Here is my blog post ... penny stocks to buy right now
This website was... how do I say it? Relevant!
! Finally I've found something which helped me. Appreciate it!
My web blog :: how to earn free money
Also see my site: tax free money market
Thank you for sharing your info. I truly appreciate your efforts
and I am waiting for your next write ups thank you once again.
Also visit my web-site: what are binary options
My family members all the time say that I am killing my time here at web, except
I know I am getting knowledge everyday by reading
thes good content.
Here is my blog penny stocks buy
Keep this going please, great job!
My homepage how to make money online fast and free
Hi, I read your blogs on a regular basis. Your humoristic style is witty,
keep it up!
Feel free to visit my page forex growth bot
It's very trouble-free to find out any topic on net as compared to textbooks, as I found this piece of writing at this web site.
Check out my webpage - binary options trading
buy tramadol order tramadol money order - buy tramadol online no prescription
http://buytramadolonlinecool.com/#63102 tramadol for dogs vs people - tramadol 50mg no prescription
http://www.integrativeonc.org/adminsio/buyklonopinonline/#5508 can you buy clonazepam - klonopin amount to overdose
buy tramadol tramadol 50 mg how many get high - tramadol for dogs can humans take it
http://buytramadolonlinecool.com/#73892 tramadol ultram dosage - buy tramadol online no prescription usa
buy klonopin online klonopin generic vs brand - klonopin duration
cheap lorazepam ativan next day side effects - ativan vs xanax vs klonopin
clonazepam without prescription what are klonopin withdrawal symptoms - klonopin 833 teva
You should take part in a contest for one of
the most useful websites on the internet. I will recommend this site!
Also visit my webpage ... make money fast online for free
Wow, that's what I was exploring for, what a material! present here at this website, thanks admin of this site.
Take a look at my web-site - binary options trading
http://southcarolinaaccidentattorney.com/#31862 buy carisoprodol online cheap - carisoprodol dosage weight
Youг own report providеs establishеԁ necessary
tο me. It’ѕ rеаlly useful and you're simply clearly very educated in this area. You possess opened my eye to be able to varying thoughts about this topic together with intriguing and reliable written content.
My weblog: Xanax
Here is my weblog :: Xanax
Yοur cuгrent article ρrovides еstablished
benefіcial to me. It’ѕ really useful and yоu're simply certainly quite educated in this area. You have exposed my sight to various opinion of this particular topic with intriguing, notable and solid content.
Look at my weblog - Buy Viagra
Also see my web site > viagra
Decide what you want in terms of features, processing
power, memory and hard drive capacity, never forgetting graphics cards, size and
quality of display and the weight and battery life. If you little bit understand technologies, you can easily root your Black - Berry.
In standard version blackberry playbook there are no support for GPRS,
EDGE and 3G.
A fast and practical netbook that may be for the more.
The result is a battery life expectancy of
around 8. The samsung chromebook is essentially a laptop that can only surf the internet and run apps.
Nice operate, Aaron. I took care of to keep my Lexmark E210 printer (an ML-1210 duplicated)
working along, now in Home windows 8.
Here is my web page :: xerox phaser 8560dn driver
This is reаlly intеresting, Үοu're an excessively skilled blogger. I have joined your feed and sit up for in search of extra of your magnificent post. Also, I have shared your web site in my social networks
Stop by my webpage :: diamondlinks review
It operates in conjunction with your i - Tunes account,
or you can have a number of other connections, based
upon what you want to view. If you don't want to use the Apple remote there is another option. You can edit and set for conversion here, such as file and title name, bit rate, frame rate, file size, frame resolution, aspect ratio, volume, and so on.
Here is my page - apple tv
It operates in conjunction with your i - Tunes account,
or you can have a number of other connections, based upon what you want to
view. If you don't want to use the Apple remote there is another option. You can edit and set for conversion here, such as file and title name, bit rate, frame rate, file size, frame resolution, aspect ratio, volume, and so on.
Feel free to surf to my page: apple tv
Section 1 - Choosing the Monochrome picture Control Section 2 -
Modifying the Monochrome Picture Control. It also shoots 1080p HD video should you feel the need.
When it comes to digital cameras, Canon offers some picture perfect solutions for the photo
moments in your life.
Feel free to surf to my page ... canon 6d
The only clicks that count toward the monthly totals come
from web searches like Google or from visitors who have clicked on
a laptop after visiting our "Notebook Database" or inside our forums.
Irrespective of class and standard, this most significant communication
tool is now important for all as we need food, water,
shelter etc. Here's why:Insulting advertising - I don't just mean the old ads that
slam Apple fans (everyone bashes on Apple fans these days).
Feel free to visit my web page: galaxy s3
It functions !!! Thanks so much !!!
my site - xerox phaser 8560 maintenance kit
I've set up Samsung Universal driver. And now my ml-1210 does not function and win 8 limiting me from transforming its driver to ml-2250, saying that current (not operating) motorist is the better one. Exactly how did you managed this?
Also visit my site; http://herseyedair.blogspot.com/2005_11_01_archive.html
Only use your AC or Heater if it is absolutely necessary.
I found the car at a truck dealership for $7000 dollars.
To save energy, the aim was for residents to program their schedules for regulating home
temperatures, which proved to be complex and not popular in use.
My web-site ... nest learning thermostat
Howdy! This blog post couldn't be written any better! Going through this post reminds me of my previous roommate! He continually kept talking about this. I will forward this article to him. Fairly certain he'll
have a great read. I appreciate you for sharing!
My web site - xerox 8560 specs
Hi there! I just wanted to ask if you ever have any trouble with hackers?
My last blog (wordpress) was hacked and I ended up losing a
few months of hard work due to no backup. Do you have any methods to protect against hackers?
my web blog - xerox 8560dn printer
Among the very best and friendly printer, easy to
use anywhere.
Feel free to visit my blog ... xerox phaser 8560 (www.escuelaameyalli.com)
Frankly, my experience says power is more important than money after working in a big mncs in the world. Choose your long run life rather than rushing behind money.
This comment has been removed by the author.
i am not here to say which one is better coz i'm myself in dilemma regarding this! but one tng that is really bothering me is that ppl are saying those who are selfish go for iims let me ask dem they are talking about power!power! power! what are they being then?
if u really want to do something gud for the country u don't have to be ias or iimian you just have to be good person with golden heart..if working in some mnc at any grade who can help someone..you are actually doing good.
so stop crying ias is for good..whatever you are you can bring a change..everything starts from smaller scale first..thanku
This are my views
Many people are reiterating that IAS can change the face of society. Please friends dont live in myth. Many IAS are those who are looting common man... Mark my words i used many, not categorically all. there are some like Khemka :).
i am claiming it. these people do
1) eat govt's money
2) they really do give shit to society, they only want to do their job. false power... neta k katputli...
3) in the name of relieving packages, or govt schemes these people spoil hard earned money of tax payer like me.
I believe in using less words..
So
Garib ko Mobile kisne diya... private sector ne.
Garib ko better life style kisne dikhai... private sector ne.
Aj dusra two wheeler afford kar sakta hai... cos of private sector. banking plays main role.
apne as pas har ek chiz dekho... you will notice and ask your self VO tumhe kiski badulat mila........
I will be glad.... ki mai HUL jise company me 30 lac white money kamau... aur logo ko ek better life do... bacche 1 rs ka jam nasib kare... aurate 3 rs me hairs dho sake... here all have power and zest to do for society...
Now ask yourself... what beauCRAPS
did for you... spare me if i am wrong... RBI and main bodies of nation Often handled my NOn-Babus...
Comments welcomes
friends see where Countries like singapore and china going.. 6 decades back we all were at same level...
what we lack... we have all the things they have... what we lack we lack pure thinking for society... who are responsible for it..you, me, private sector or Govt decision makers......think from heart... At least ias aspirants know why this happened... I think lack of policies.
Whatever india achieved many say it will be 3rd largest economy by 30 years... It achieved because of Privaye sector... and companies like NTPC and ONGC god sake they are utility... vo bikna hi hai... kal ja ke Monopoly start kar do... Indian Chicken... aram se 1 T$ profit earner rahoge...
hi everyone.. my question is that whether ias officer have peaceful life with his family.?? whether he will have time to spend with his family?? more than power and money peaceful life is much more important.
hey everyone, i am highly confused between ias or iim. i have cleared the IPM test in IIM-Indore. I have two options. Either go and join IIM-I or drop it and go for IAS. My ultimate goal is IAS only. Should i go through IIM or do history hons or some other simpler course to get into it? please help
hey everyone, i am highly confused between ias or iim. i have cleared the IPM test in IIM-Indore. I have two options. Either go and join IIM-I or drop it and go for IAS. My ultimate goal is IAS only. Should i go through IIM or do history hons or some other simpler course to get into it? please help
Hey,
Go for IAS, without any doubt !!
IAS officer - wow what a proud feeling !! what a respect !!
Amazing !!
IIM - people will not even recognize you!!
Deepak
IAS ran so many PSUs to ground. IAS salaries come from taxes of private sector. Only people from underdeveloped states respect IAS.People from better developed states know their rights. Many IAS and IPS officers are sent to jail for misuse of power by complaint from common man in developed states. In terms of power, judges enjoy supreme power. I have seen ministers and IAS officers standing up even when a district judge comes leave alone high court or supreme court judges.
I’ve been browsing on-line greater than three hours today, but I never discovered any attention-grabbing article like yours. It is beautiful worth sufficient for me. Personally, if all webmasters and bloggers made good content material as you did, the net will be a lot more helpful than ever before.
CAT coaching in chennai
CAT training centre in chennai
Best CAT Coaching in Chennai
Thanks for Sharing Quality information With us Top mba institutes | AICTE approved B Schools
I am in a confusion of choose between Civil services preparation and Higher studies. This post let me know the advantages of civil services career. I am very thankful to you for sharing such as nice post.
Best IAS Academy in Chennai
Top 10 IAS Academy in Chennai
UPSC Coaching in Chennai
Hey guys...I am extremely confused between MBA from Top Institutes or IAS.I have always dreamt of having more money since my childhood and that is why the MBA option but their are few who says I am not guaranteed high package even after getting into IIM.Can you all please help me to decide between these two
Post a Comment
<< Home